Sugar Free Vanilla Coffee Creamer

posted in: Holistic Wellness | 4

I love creamer in my coffee, but I've never found a store-bought version that is both a.) sugar free and b.) made with real-food ingredients.

And while it's easy to simply add a splash of cream, stevia and vanilla to your cup of coffee, it's also really easy to go overboard on any of those ingredients. Mixing up a batch of this creamer saves a lot of time, and gets you caffeinated perfection every time !

Sugar Free Vanilla Coffee Creamer

Sugar Free Vanilla Coffee Creamer Recipe


  • 1.5 cups of heavy cream
  • 1/2 cup milk – I use whole, but that's up to you. 😉
  • 9 grams (packets) powdered stevia OR 1/2 tsp stevia extract
  • 1 tbsp vanilla extract


I add the stevia, vanilla, and milk to my container first, then shake it up really well to combine.

Then, I add the cream half a cup at a time, shaking each time. You can see very clearly if the vanilla is not mixing in, so keep mixing until the creamer is a uniform color.

I also shake the creamer each time I use it.

It's really that simple!

This recipe makes a barely-sweet creamer that I'm crazy about. You could easily add more stevia to sweeten it up even more.

Sugar Free Vanilla Coffee Creamer


I would love to experiment with making this creamer using different extracts!

What flavors do you like in your coffee?

Share this:
Follow Kylie Wiser:

Kylie Wiser is an herbalist, writer, and educator on plant-based living. She founded Everblossom in 2009.

4 Responses

  1. heather

    where has this been my whole life? My hubby swears by flavored creamer in his coffee and this would be perfect for him!!

  2. Sherry

    Thanks! I will definitely be trying this soon. We go through a lot of French vanilla creamer at our house.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *