Sugar Free Vanilla Coffee Creamer

posted in: Holistic Wellness | 4

I love creamer in my coffee, but I've never found a store-bought version that is both a.) sugar free and b.) made with real-food ingredients.

And while it's easy to simply add a splash of cream, stevia and vanilla to your cup of coffee, it's also really easy to go overboard on any of those ingredients. Mixing up a batch of this creamer saves a lot of time, and gets you caffeinated perfection every time !

Sugar Free Vanilla Coffee Creamer

Sugar Free Vanilla Coffee Creamer Recipe


  • 1.5 cups of heavy cream
  • 1/2 cup milk – I use whole, but that's up to you. 😉
  • 9 grams (packets) powdered stevia OR 1/2 tsp stevia extract
  • 1 tbsp vanilla extract


I add the stevia, vanilla, and milk to my container first, then shake it up really well to combine.

Then, I add the cream half a cup at a time, shaking each time. You can see very clearly if the vanilla is not mixing in, so keep mixing until the creamer is a uniform color.

I also shake the creamer each time I use it.

It's really that simple!

This recipe makes a barely-sweet creamer that I'm crazy about. You could easily add more stevia to sweeten it up even more.

Sugar Free Vanilla Coffee Creamer


I would love to experiment with making this creamer using different extracts!

What flavors do you like in your coffee?


Stay on top of your self care game and get the latest updates and resources delivered straight to your inbox. (It's free!)

Follow Kylie Wiser:

Kylie Wiser is an herbalist specializing in skincare and women's health. She shares recipes and resources on Everblossom to help others live a more holistic lifestyle. She lives in Fargo, ND with her huge family and lots of houseplants.

Latest posts from

4 Responses

  1. heather

    where has this been my whole life? My hubby swears by flavored creamer in his coffee and this would be perfect for him!!

  2. Sherry

    Thanks! I will definitely be trying this soon. We go through a lot of French vanilla creamer at our house.

Leave a Reply to heather Cancel reply